China has used extra surveillance and restrictions ostensibly imposed because of the Covid-19 pandemic to block the work of foreign reporters already struggling with threats of detention and punitive visa restrictions, a press group said Monday.
As the country has largely brought the coronavirus outbreak under control since it emerged in late 2019, Beijing has raced to promote an official narrative of heroism and success in its early handling of the pandemic.
“As China’s propaganda machine struggled to regain control of the narrative around this public health disaster, foreign press outlets were repeatedly obstructed in their attempts to cover the pandemic,” the Foreign Correspondents’ Club of China (FCCC) said in its annual report, based on a survey of 150 of its 220 members.
“China has used the pandemic as yet another way to control journalists.”
Strict Covid-19 measures have been regularly used to block or threaten reporters, the media group said, with some 42 percent of respondents saying they had been made to leave an area or denied access for health and safety reasons.
The FCCC said journalists were asked to comply with measures that were not required of others, and that the introduction of coronavirus checkpoints and contact tracing apps had created “additional opportunities for Chinese authorities to gather data and surveil foreign journalists and their sources.”
4/ China has used the coronavirus pandemic create more restrictions for foreign press – restrictions that exceed those for everyone else. 21% said they were locked out last year, and journalists remain the one group of resident permits holders still barred from entering China.
— Foreign Correspondents’ Club of China (@fccchina) March 1, 2021
Sources like medical staff in the central city of Wuhan — where Covid-19 first surfaced — were interrogated by authorities or warned against accepting interviews, reporters said.
For a third straight year, none of the respondents said working conditions had improved.
Asked about the report Monday, a Chinese official said that it was “presumptuous, alarmist and has zero factual basis”.
“We have always welcomed media and journalists from all countries to carry out interviews and reporting in China, in accordance with laws and regulations,” said foreign ministry spokesman Wang Wenbin.
“We oppose ideological prejudice targeting China, the concoction of fake news under the pretext of so-called media freedom, and behaviour that violates journalistic ethics.”
As relations worsened between China and several western countries, 2020 also saw “the largest expulsion of foreign journalists since the aftermath of the Tiananmen Square massacre more than three decades ago”, the FCCC said.
7/ Our Chinese colleagues are interrogated regularly by state security or police on reporting trips and also in their hometowns, vilified on social media, and accused of being unpatriotic. Sometimes they are even detained.
— Foreign Correspondents’ Club of China (@fccchina) March 1, 2021
In the second half of the year, foreign journalists became “pawns in a diplomatic spat” when state security officers told two Australian media correspondents they were barred from leaving the country, it noted.
The pair sought refuge in Australian diplomatic missions before fleeing the country.
Since September, authorities stopped issuing new press cards to US news organisations’ correspondents as relations worsened between the two countries, the FCCC said.
The survey also warned that foreign news outlets have been targeted in disinformation campaigns by state media, including claims that their interviewees were paid actors.
Support HKFP | Policies & Ethics | Error/typo? | Contact Us | Newsletter | Transparency & Annual Report | Apps
Help safeguard press freedom & keep HKFP free for all readers by supporting our team
LATEST ON COVID-19 IN HONG KONG
HKFP GUIDES
