Hong Kong’s government is defending the city’s ban on same-sex unions at a landmark court challenge days after neighbouring Taiwan legalised gay marriage in an unprecedented first for Asia.
Despite growing public support for gay marriage in the international financial hub, campaigners have made little headway against staunch opposition from the city’s successive pro-Beijing governments and religious conservatives.
A Hong Kong woman, known only as MK, is suing the government for denying her right to enter into a civil partnership with her female partner, arguing the ban is unconstitutional.
The case is currently being heard by the Court of First Instance.
Defending the current ban, government lawyer Stewart Wong told the court Wednesday that marriage would be “diluted and diminished” and “no longer special” if that right was granted to same-sex couples.
Not all differences in treatment are unlawful. You are not supposed to treat unequal cases alike,” Wong said, adding that Hong Kong’s definition of marriage was already defined by law and “cannot be trumped”.
He also argued against same-sex civil unions.
“To recognise an alternative form of same-sex relationships which we say is tantamount to a (marriage) is to undermine the traditional institution of marriage and the family constituted by such a marriage,” Wong said.
The Hong Kong government’s view stands in stark contrast to nearby Taiwan where lawmakers made history approving Asia’s first gay marriage law earlier this month, despite a conservative backlash.
There were jubilant scenes in Taipei as the first same-sex couples were wed with government officials saying they hoped the move would also draw more international business.
A poll last year by Hong Kong University found public support for gay marriage had risen to 50 percent, a 12 percent increase in four years.
City authorities last week belatedly approved a Cathay Pacific advert featuring two men holding hands, after its reported ban sparked an outcry.
But the city’s government remains unmoved.
In a recent radio interview, even the head of Hong Kong’s equality watchdog said it was “impractical” and a “waste of resources” to push for marriage equality, Hong Kong Free Press reported.
At a conference on Wednesday exploring the city’s inclusion of gay employees, lawyer Michael Vidler told delegates the city’s business figures had a uniquely strong influence on the local government.
“It (the government) listens to business far more than to NGOs,” he said.
Instead, the fight for gay rights in Hong Kong has largely ended up in the courts.
On Tuesday MK’s lawyer, Gladys Li, argued that it is “now or never” for Hong Kong’s LGBT couples to secure civil partnership and marriage rights.
Li likened marriage to a “private members’ club” when limited only to heterosexual couples.
Hong Kong does not recognise same-sex marriage or civil unions and only decriminalised homosexuality in 1991.
But a British lesbian won the right to live and work in Hong Kong with her partner in a landmark ruling last year hailed by rights groups.
A separate case has been lodged by two Hong Kong men directly challenging the same-sex marriage ban as unconstitutional.
And a transgender pastor from a church that welcomes gay congregants has sought permission to launch his own legal challenge, arguing his inability to perform same-sex ceremonies breaches his community’s religious freedoms.
Hong Kong’s psychedelic disco rock superstars Shumking Mansion will play this year’s Hong Kong Free Press 2019 fundraising party at the Hive Spring in Wong Chuk Hang. Tickets are available now for a minimum donation of just HK$50 in advance (free for HKFP monthly donors).
- University of Hong Kong appoints mainland professors as vice-presidents amid concerns over academic freedom
- EXCLUSIVE: Only 17% of Hongkongers approve of proposal to allow HK election voting in China despite Lam claim – HKFP-PORI poll
- Covid-19: Beaches to reopen on Fri, dine-in limit raised to 6 people – but 4-person public gathering limit to stay