Four musicians from the UK and US have given recorded statements at the Immigration Department, after they were arrested on Sunday night for playing at independent music venue Hidden Agenda without a work visa.

Venue founder Hui Chung-wo and two other members of staff arrested have not yet been released as of Monday afternoon, despite spending some 16 hours detained by police.

Update: Lawmakers question tight rules over industrial building music venues following arrest of Hidden Agenda performers

The seven arrests were made following a raid at a concert at the Kwun Tong industrial building venue, featuring UK band This Town Needs Guns, US band Mylets, and Hong Kong group Emptybottles.

Hui Chung-wo Hidden Agenda
Hui Chung-wo in a police van on Sunday night. Photo: Facebook/Hidden Agenda.

Immigration officers posed as concert-goers and attended the performances in order to collect evidence that the bands had been hired by the venue. As the concert ended, they asked to conduct an investigation at the premises. Police then received a report of fighting, and officers armed with riot shields and police dogs arrived at the scene.

The Immigration Department told HKFP that the three British musicians and sole US performer are suspected of breaching their conditions of stay.

Police told HKFP that the three venue staffers have been charged variously with obstructing a police officer in exercise of duties and common assault.

Departing Hong Kong

Pro-democracy lawmakers Jeremy Tam and Tanya Chan accompanied the four foreign musicians on Monday afternoon as they made recorded statements at Kowloon Bay’s Immigration Department offices.

Speaking on behalf of the musicians, Tam said they would fully cooperate with the Immigration Department and police investigations. But they hoped that the department would allow them to leave Hong Kong temporarily.

Jeremy Tam Tanya Chan This Town Needs Guns Mylets
Legislators Jeremy Tam and Tanya Chan accompanying members of This Town Needs Guns and Mylets outside Kowloon Bay’s Immigration Department office. Photo: HKFP/Elson Tong.

According to Tam, three musicians have purchased a flight ticket departing on Tuesday evening back to the UK, while the final musician is scheduled to leave on Wednesday morning to the US via mainland China.

He added that the musicians would return to Hong Kong to assist in the department’s investigation some point in the future if required.

Change of immigration policy?

Tam, who arrived at Hidden Agenda on Sunday night following news of the raid, said the four musicians were represented by two lawyers – solicitor Ng Gene Bond, and barrister Tanya Chan.

Tam added that founder Hui and the two venue staffers also had legal representation. However, solicitor Ng told HKFP he did not know when the trio would be released.

The Immigration Department told HKFP that Hidden Agenda has previously applied for – and successfully obtained – work visas for overseas performing artists. “However, the department found that the unit did not apply for a work visa for the performers in question [on Sunday night], and is investigating whether there have been any breaches of the law.”

Jeremy Tam Man-ho
Legislator Jeremy Tam. Photo: HKFP/Elson Tong.

Tam said on Monday afternoon he believed that the department has changed its policy on issuing work visas to overseas artists: “Previously they would not ask whether location of a performance is an industrial building.”

“But in these past few months, they ask whether you are performing in an industrial building,” he said. “If so, they would not issue work visas.”

He added that this change in policy did not only affect musicians playing at Hidden Agenda, but also for artists visiting other unlicensed industrial building facilities across Hong Kong.

See also: UK & US performers among 7 arrested in fresh raid at indie music venue Hidden Agenda

Under the Immigration Ordinance, breaching conditions of stay in Hong Kong carries a maximum fine of HK$50,000 and two years’ imprisonment. An employer who unlawfully employs an immigrant faces a maximum fine of HK$350,000 and three years’ imprisonment.

Tam speculated that the refusal of visas was caused by the department’s fear of “getting into trouble” within the government bureaucracy for not implementing licensing regulations to the letter of the law.

Jeremy Tam This Town Needs Guns Mylets
Musicians were led by legislator Jeremy Tam to make recorded statements. Photo: HKFP/Elson Tong.

“This strangles the music industry,” he said. “This creates a very bad image as to how we treat overseas musicians in Hong Kong.”

“I’m actually very proud of the achievements of Hidden Agenda, it’s a well-known live house… But it’s not supported by the government at all.”

The venue has been subjected to numerous raids at each of its four locations since its establishment in 2009, primarily related to violations of the terms of its land lease.

See also: Video: Hong Kong indie music venue Hidden Agenda raided by police and officials

Responding to HKFP’s enquiries, a spokesperson for the US Consulate said it was aware of the situation: “We take our obligation to assist US citizens abroad seriously.”

Likewise, a British Consulate spokesperson told HKFP that it was in contact with the Hong Kong authorities: “We are providing support to the British nationals.”

Elson Tong

Elson Tong

Elson Tong is a graduate of international relations and former investigations consultant. He has also written for Stand News.