Hong Kong journalist Bao Choy has furthered her chance of appealing her conviction over accessing car licence information for an investigative documentary about a mob attack in Yuen Long in July 2019.

Bao Choy high court appeal 721 yuen long RTHK documentary
The High Court granted journalist Bao Choy a certificate that would allow her to appeal her conviction for access car licence data for an investigative documentary on November 18, 2022. Photo: Almond Li/HKFP.

The High Court granted Choy a certificate to apply for leave to appeal, moving the journalist a step along the convoluted appeal procedure.

High Court judge Alex Lee said some of the legal arguments raised by Choy were of “great and general importance” and should be further deliberated by the Court of Final Appeal.

Lee rejected Choy’s first appeal earlier this month, saying he agreed with the ruling of the initial magistrate that information obtained through the database of vehicle details cannot be “arbitrarily abused.”

Lee, Alex 李運騰.JPG
Justice Alex Lee. Photo: Judiciary.

Choy, a freelance producer, was arrested in November 2020 and charged with two counts of making false statements to obtain vehicle records for a documentary for public broadcaster RTHK.

The 22-minute documentary uncovered details about the mob attack in Yuen Long on July 21, 2019, widely seen as a turning point in the protests that summer with police accused of siding with the attackers and ignoring calls for help.

She was found guilty last year and fined HK$6,000, a verdict that prompted fears about declining press freedom in the city. The conviction was condemned by the city’s press club and rights groups as an affront to press freedom, since the press often uses such data in the course of regular reporting.

Questions of law

In applying to launch a legal challenge, Choy’s legal team raised two questions of law. The first one was regarding the power of the transport commissioner to refuse applications from the public to obtain vehicle registration information.

“Does regulation 4(2) of the Road Traffic (Registrate and Licensing of Vehicles) Regulations (Cap. 374E) empower the Commissioner for Transport to refuse to supply a certificate as mentioned in that provision to an applicant unless the applicant’s purpose of the application was related to traffic and transport matters?” Choy’s team put it to the court.

Lee proposed rewording it to: “Under regulation 4(2) of the Road Traffic (Registrate and Licensing of Vehicles) Regulations (Capt. 374E), can the Commissioner for Transport refuse to supply a certificate to an applicant on the ground that the applicant’s purpose of the application is not connected with ‘traffic and transport related matters?'”

Tien Kei-rui, who represented Choy, said they would accept the judge’s suggestion.

police men white shirt Yuen Long
A screenshot of investigative documentary “721 Yuen Long Nightmare”. Photo: RTHK screenshot.

In the second legal argument, the journalist asked “how should the phrase ‘traffic and transport related matters’ be construed” – and whether it included “journalistic investigation into or involving the use of a vehicle on the road.”

Lee suggested changing it to “[d]oes it cover an investigation by a journalist into the identity of a person suspected to be involved in a crime (not being a traffic offence) when that person is believed to have used a private vehicle to get to and/or away from the crime scene.”

Tien rejected the amendment, arguing that the purpose of applying for access to information could be wider than just identifying someone. Lee interrupted the barrister, saying during Choy’s trial, it was agreed that the information was used to produce 721 Yuen Long Nightmare.

RTHK July 21, 2019 Yuen Long Police
The man in a red circle on the right is suspected to be a plainclothes officer. The other man in circle appear to have a weapon in his hand. Photo: RTHK screenshot.

“Are you going to tell me she did not have that purpose in mind when she applied to obtain this information?” Lee questioned Tien. “Do not joke with me.”

Choy “had made phone calls and tried to schedule interviews,” Lee added. “Do not tell me she did not think that way.”

Tien said identifying an individual could be one of the directions, but there could also be other purposes. Lee said he was not satisfied and would not sign off the second argument if Choy’s side did not rephrase it.

‘Great and general importance’

Lee ruled that the first question of law was of “great and general importance, especially for the news industry.” He added it may also affect members of the public who might need vehicle registration data for other purposes like litigation – matters unrelated to traffic or transport.

Bao Choy high court appeal 721 yuen long RTHK documentary
Bao Choy met the press on November 18, 2022. Photo: Almond Li/HKFP.

As for the second legal argument, Choy said they would file an application to the Appeal Committee of the Court of Final Appeal and let it determine whether she had grounds to launch a challenge.

Bao Choy high court appeal 721 yuen long RTHK documentary
Bao Choy. Photo: Almond Li/HKFP.

Speaking to the press after the hearing, Choy said she had expected her appeal process to go all the way to the city’s top court, so she felt calm and was not too bothered.

“So I didn’t really have a lot of… worries about the consequence, whether I will win or lose the case, I guess what I’m doing is just trying to continue to pursue justice and I understand that I’m not doing that by myself,” Choy said.

Correction 6/12/2022: An earlier version of the article stated that the High Court had granted Choy leave to appeal her conviction. In fact, the High Court granted Choy a certificate that is required for lodging a leave to appeal.

Support HKFP  |  Code of Ethics  |  Error/typo?  |  Contact Us  |  Newsletter  | Transparency & Annual Report | Apps

Help safeguard press freedom & keep HKFP free for all readers by supporting our team

contribute to hkfp
2023 fund hkfp
YouTube video

Support press freedom & help us surpass 1,000 monthly Patrons: 100% independent, governed by an ethics code & not-for-profit.

contact hkfp
Almond Li

Almond Li

Almond Li is a Hong Kong-based journalist who previously worked for Reuters and Happs TV as a freelancer, and as a reporter at Hong Kong International Business Channel, Citizen News and Commercial Radio Hong Kong. She earned her Masters in Journalism at the University of Southern California. She has an interest in LGBT+, mental health and environmental issues.