By Su Xinqi

For mainlanders in Hong Kong, the city’s protests pose a complicated challenge, with even some who backed the demonstrations now wary of a movement that has become vocally and sometimes even violently anti-China.

Christine Wang moved to Hong Kong from the mainland seven years ago, and sympathised with the initial demands of protesters opposed to legislation allowing extraditions to China.

mainland Chinese man Qixian Ye
This picture taken on November 7, 2019 shows a mainland Chinese man, using the pseudonym “Qixian Ye”, posing for a photo after an interview with AFP in Hong Kong. Photo by Philip FONG/AFP.

“I did not support the bill. But the bill was one issue, and what happened later, including the damaging acts that emerged, are another issue,” the 33-year-old told AFP.

Like other mainlanders who spoke to AFP, Wang asked to use a pseudonym, fearing reprisals in an increasingly febrile atmosphere where those perceived to back the government or Beijing have been the target of verbal and physical abuse.

She works part-time as both a university research assistant and in insurance sales. Business has plunged up to 80 percent in recent months, she says, with demonstrations paralysing commerce in parts of the city.

But Wang says it is less the financial impact of the protests than violence and intimidation by protesters that have her questioning the movement.

YouTube video

Crowds of pro-democracy activists have beaten ideological opponents and smashed up shops accused of backing the government and Beijing.

In November, a firebrand pro-Beijing politician was stabbed by a man pretending to be a supporter. He survived.

The violence has not been one-sided.

Protesters have also come under attack, accusing police of turning a blind eye when supporters of the government and Beijing have assaulted demonstrators and politicians.

‘Stop hurting people’

“I still support their rights to express themselves and protest,” Wang said.

“But I hope some normal life can be restored soon and they can stop hurting people and damaging shops.”

August 12 extradition protester eye protest

More than one million mainland Chinese have moved to Hong Kong since British rule ended in 1997, but there are no public figures on the numbers currently in the city.

And the community’s views on the political unrest are hard to gauge, with no accurate surveys on the opinions of people sometimes known as “Hong Kong drifters”.

A survey of 268 mainland students in the city’s Chinese University in September, conducted by fellow students, found 35 percent backed the protests and an equal number opposed them.

Earlier this month, scores of mainland students left Hong Kong after multiple campuses became battlegrounds between police and protesters.

Wang says she doesn’t feel physically threatened but worries about the use by both sides of epithets like “loser” and “brainwashed”, and a hardening of the divide between “Hong Konger” and “Chinese” identities.

“It feels like one side is wielding extreme nationalism and the other nativism or populism, and I worry about both.”

‘Manipulated campaign’ 

Alice Zhang, 28, has studied and worked in Hong Kong for six years and said the protests took her by surprise.

Benjamin Yuen Jordan 5 November 18
Photo: Benjamin Yuen/United Social Press.

“I never thought a city could be that united and everyone could fight that hard for something that’s not just about personal interests,” she said.

She blames the increasing violence and vitriol on misinformation from both sides.

“Most of the protesters in Hong Kong are not anti-China, instead they are opposing the policies and plans laid out for Hong Kong by China’s ruling party.”

A landslide victory by pro-democracy candidates in recent district council elections showed the need for the government to address protester grievances, she added.

“The disturbances in the past few months are largely due to the ignorance and repetition of empty talk by the chief executive and her government.”

While some mainlanders head to Hong Kong for its comparative freedoms, others are drawn for purely economic reasons, and for them the protests hold less appeal.

PLA Baptist University Kowloon Tong
PLA personnel clear debris by Hong Kong Baptist University in Kowloon Tong. Photo: Kris Cheng/HKFP.

Qixian Ye, a 30-year-old finance worker, said his generation had grown up with pride in China’s economic development, “which may make many of us believe it’s okay to compromise some rights for economic growth.”

Others are more direct.

Louise Liu, a marketing professional who came from the mainland 13 years ago, calls the protests a “manipulated campaign” that is “anti-China.”

“Is it democracy when people like me get beaten up when we speak our minds?”

Hong Kong Free Press relies on direct reader support. Help safeguard independent journalism and press freedom as we invest more in freelancers, overtime, safety gear & insurance during this summer’s protests. 10 ways to support us.

fundraising fundraise banner

AFP is a global news agency delivering fast, in-depth coverage of the events shaping our world from wars and conflicts to politics, sports, entertainment and the latest breakthroughs in health, science and technology.