By Catherine Lai

Hong Kong’s pro-democracy protesters boast of a broad support base but their movement has divided some neighbourhoods, including Wong Tai Sin, where many police officers live.

Poppy Chan, the wife of a police officer, was preparing dinner for her family when she heard the crash of a brick shattering the window of her third-floor apartment.

This picture taken on August 9, 2019 shows a woman walking past pamphlets for the pro-democracy campaign in the Wong Tai Sin district of Hong Kong. Photo: Manan Vatsyayana/AFP.

Tear gas flooded the home she shares with her two young daughters, her husband, and a domestic worker, in a complex where many police live with their families.

“At that moment, I was more scared than angry,” she told AFP.

“Maybe they don’t know that what they’re doing is very wrong.”

“I just think it’s really sad, because it seems like they’re being used by others,” she added.

Chan’s family had cowered inside the apartment during three days of running protests in the neighbourhood. When the brick came sailing into their home, she decided it was time to leave.

She packed some of their belongings and fled to a friend’s place.

Wong Tai Sin. Photo: May James/HKFP.

The Wong Tai Sin neighbourhood has seen some of the worst clashes in protests that began in opposition to a bill allowing extraditions to mainland China.

The protests have morphed into a broader movement seeking greater democratic freedoms in the international financial hub.

It has won support from a cross section of society, with lawyers, civil servants, older people and parents with small children turning out to rallies.

‘Enforce the law’

But in Wong Tai Sin, some are more ambivalent about protesters who accuse the police of brutality and have hurled bricks at officers and their homes.

Wong Tai Sin. Photo: May James/HKFP.

“Throughout this entire thing, I have rarely felt anger, because I always think that sometimes people don’t know what they’re doing,” Chan said.

Other residents of the working class neighbourhood are less forgiving of the demonstrators who targeted the local police station on August 3, spraying graffiti and dismantling security cameras.

Joe, a 35-year-old middle school mathematics teacher who declined to give his family name, called the demonstrators “lawless” and “destructive.”

He wants to see the government crack down harder.

“You must be willing to enforce the law and use the power and the force at your disposal without fear to suppress the destructive actions of these rioters,” he said.

“They will take advantage of the weak response from the government and the police, and the victims will be the whole of Hong Kong, including innocent civilians like me.”

Photo: May James/HKFP.

There are no recent independent opinion polls to confirm the level of support for demonstrators, though protesters point to the massive turnout at rallies in June and the fact that they continue to draw supporters to rallies three months into their movement.

Demonstrations in support of police or the government have drawn much smaller numbers.

‘Cruel to both sides’

There are also signs that the police response has at times backfired, encouraging residents sitting on the sidelines to throw their support behind the demonstrators.

When clashes erupted in Wong Tai Sin on August 3, police found themselves facing a massive crowd of angry residents who came out of their homes, some wearing flip-flops, screaming “leave” and “you’re not welcome in Wong Tai Sin.”


21-year-old student Chow, who gave only his family name, was heading home when he saw riot police using batons and tear gas against protesters and residents alike in the melee.

“I saw them rush from the vehicles and start hitting the group of residents. Some were grandpas, uncles, youngsters, and I even saw a bus driver,” he said.

“If they can use their batons to hit them, if they can do this to ordinary civilians… then how can I trust the police in the future?”

He had not joined protests before then, but the incident prompted him to begin.

Photo: May James/HKFP.

“The events that night absolutely turned me from someone who is quite neutral into a yellow state,” he said, referring to the yellow associated with the pro-democracy movement.

And even some who don’t actively back the protests are angered by what they consider an inept government response.

“I think it’s quite cruel to both sides,” said 58-year-old local resident Amy Lee.

“Government officials created the present situation, but the frontline (officers) are the ones being sent out.”

AFP is a global news agency delivering fast, in-depth coverage of the events shaping our world from wars and conflicts to politics, sports, entertainment and the latest breakthroughs in health, science and technology.