Embattled University of Hong Kong law professor Benny Tai has said he fears for his personal freedom and suspects he is under surveillance. His comments came after a photo of him appeared in a pro-Beijing newspaper, despite him checking that he was not being followed.

Tai was recently condemned by the Hong Kong and central governments over hypothetical comments about Hong Kong independence. He said he suspected he was being monitored by “powerful agencies” related to China, referring to those who may have “kidnapped” Hong Kong booksellers.

Tai said he realised he was being followed by reporters from the state-owned Ta Kung Pao newspaper last Saturday, after spotting pictures of himself out dining with friends.

Benny Tai. Photo: Citizen News.

He said that, on Sunday, he carefully checked to see if there were any suspicious vehicles after he left his flat in his car. However, by the next day, he noticed that Ta Kung Pao had printed a photo of him in a car park in Central. He had been at a nearby building for around 50 minutes.

Tai said he suspected that, if reporters had not followed him from his flat, his computer, phone or his car may have been monitored.

‘Powerful agencies’ 

He said he respected press freedom but would not tolerate surveillance: “Because of incidents over the past few years in Hong Kong, powerful agencies are the number one suspect.”

Tai said he may be over-sensitive or may have failed to see reporters’ cars following him, but he has nevertheless feared for his personal freedom.

“If you ask me why I did not go to the police, I can only say that – if it was the work of powerful agencies – Hong Kong police cannot help. I may be charged with a false police report or wasting police resources. Thus, I can only seek help from Hong Kong people,” he said.

“Let me make a statement: If you see me leaving Hong Kong ports or entering mainland China or Macau on my own, or with someone, please ask me if I am voluntarily leaving Hong Kong,” he added. “If you see me in mainland China or Macau, I did not go there voluntarily, because I have no intention to go there.”

“If you see some video of me saying that I voluntarily returned to mainland China or Macau, I must have said that under pressure or threats.”


Posted by Tai Yiu Ting, 戴耀廷 on Tuesday, 3 April 2018

Tai, one of the founders of the 2014 pro-democracy Occupy protests, attended a forum in Taiwan last week. He told the audience that, should China become a democratic country, different groups in China could consider becoming independent countries, or parts of a federation or confederation.

The government then issued a rare statement last Friday saying that it was “shocked” by Tai’s remarks and strongly condemned them. The China Liaison Office in Hong Kong and the Hong Kong and Macao Affairs Office in Beijing both issued statements condemning Tai.

The overseas edition of state mouthpiece the People’s Daily printed a commentary urging the government to take action against Tai, saying he violated the Crimes Ordinance’s section on seditious intention.

Pro-China groups also protested at his university demanding he be sacked.

Kris Cheng

Kris Cheng is a Hong Kong journalist with an interest in local politics. His work has been featured in Washington Post, Public Radio International, Hong Kong Economic Times and others. He has a BSSc in Sociology from the Chinese University of Hong Kong. Kris is HKFP's Editorial Director.