Hong Kong’s pro-democracy camp has won two out of four seats in Sunday’s Legislative Council by-elections, which they deemed a de facto “referendum” against the disqualification of opposition lawmakers. Gary Fan in New Territories East and Au Nok-hin in Hong Kong Island both emerged victorious, but the pro-Beijing camp gained the upper hand in West Kowloon and the architectural sector.
Previously ousted lawmaker Edward Yiu failed to regain his seat, but demanded a recount as he was trailing just 2,000 votes behind eventual victor Vincent Cheng. Yiu ran in the architectural sector in 2016 before he was ejected from the legislature over protests he made during his oath-taking. On Sunday, he ran in the Kowloon West geographical constituency.
Yiu told reporters that he may not have displayed enough campaign materials in the district, but denied his campaign had neglected grassroots voters: “We started our campaign too late… as we had to wait until the confirmation of my declaration from a returning officer on the 29th of January.”
The overall turnout for the three geographical constituencies – Hong Kong Island, Kowloon West, and New Territories East – stood at 43 per cent, one of the lowest in recent elections. The turnout for the small-circle Architectural, Surveying, Planning and Landscape functional constituency stood at 70 per cent – around nine per cent lower than in the 2016 general legislative election.
On Hong Kong Island, pro-democracy candidate Au Nok-hin beat pro-Beijing candidate Judy Chan with 137,181 votes to her 127,634. Earlier on Sunday, Chan accused her rival of “self-orchestrating” attacks on his campaign team after pro-establishment protesters hurled abuse in Aberdeen.
Au said his win was a “pyrrhic victory” as he was only able to make campaign plans in a short period of time after Demosisto’s Agnes Chow was banned from entering the race: “This election should not have happened at all in the first place,” he said.
In New Territories East, pro-democracy candidate Gary Fan gained 183,762 votes, beating pro-Beijing candidate Bill Tang who attracted 155,904. Fan said there will be a lot of reflections necessary over the election.
In the Architectural, Surveying, Planning and Landscape functional constituency, pro-Beijing candidate Tony Tse – a former lawmaker of the sector – beat pro-democracy candidate Paul Zimmerman by 584 votes. Tse won the support of 2,929 voters compared to Zimmerman’s 2,345.
”Results in full“
1 Edward Yiu 105,060
2 Vincent Cheng 107,479
3 Jonathan Tsoi 2,794
Hong Kong Island
1 Au Nok-hin 137,181
2 Ng Dick-hay 2,202
3 Edward Yum 3,580
4 Judy Chan 127,634
New Territories East:
1 Nelson Wong 6,182
2 Christine Fong 64,905
3 Estella Chan 1,504
4 Bill Tang 155,904
5 Joyce Chiu 3,068
6 Gary Fan 183,762
1 Tony Tse 2,929
2 Paul Zimmerman 2,345
The legislature now consists of 26 pro-democracy and 42 pro-Beijing candidates, meaning democrats still lack the power to veto legislation.
The by-election was triggered after four lawmakers were ousted by the High Court following an interpretation of Article 104 of the Basic Law by Beijing. They were among six who faced legal action for inappropriately taking their oaths of office upon initially being elected in 2016. Ex-lawmakers Leung Kwok-hung and Lau Siu-lai are still appealing their disqualifications.
A full round-up of our by-election stories:
- Disqualified lawmaker’s defeat shows public back gov’t, says pro-Beijing lawmaker
- President of legislature says he is not worried about repeat of oath-taking row
- Pro-Beijing hopeful Judy Chan accuses rival of ‘self-orchestrating’ scuffles
- ‘Parachuted in’ Edward Yiu lost over lack of district work, says academic
- Gary Fan secures support from democratic camp, but failed to win over localists
- Taxi unionists in legal bid to disqualify pro-democracy winner Au Nok-hin
- Inexperience cost me the election, says defeated democrat Edward Yiu
- Pro-democracy candidates make emergency call for votes amid low turnout
- Cathay Pacific union condemns ‘impersonators’ asking members to vote for pro-BJ candidate
Not-for-profit, run by journalists and completely independent – thank you for reading Hong Kong Free Press. Contribute to our critical month-long HK$1m Funding Drive, help safeguard our independence and secure our operations for another year. Read how carefully we spend every cent in our Annual/Transparency Report.