The government’s decision to cut down four banyan trees based on cracks on a stone fence above them on Bonham Road has been criticised by experts as “misguided.”

The Geotechnical Engineering Office (GEO)—an arm of the Civil Engineering and Development Department—said on Tuesday that the wall where the four trees were growing out of was actually divided into two parts.

sai ying pun kennedy town
The four remaining banyan trees were cut down by the Highways Department today more than a week after a large tree on the same wall was uprooted during a storm. Photo: Sai Wan Concern.

According to Ming Pao, the GEO said the four trees grew from the main wall. The Highways Department based its decision to cut down the trees on cracks that appeared on a stone fence above the wall, a section that was not supporting the four trees.

A statement by the Highways Department said they found 16 cracks on the stone fence on August 7, with the largest one being 2cm long. The department then acknowledged that “there was nothing in the stone [fence] itself that suggested there was any immediate danger.”

bonham road centre street
A total of sixteen cracks were found on part of a stone wall that was completely separate from the wall the four banyan trees were growing out of. Photo: HKFP.

The announcement came just a few days after the Highways Department decided to cut down the four trees, citing public safety concerns after two people were injured when a large banyan tree on the same road was uprooted during a storm.

The tree—said to be the tallest in Hong Kong growing out of a stone wall—was one of six on the Bonham Road and Centre Street intersection. After it fell, the Tree Management Office decided to remove one that was in bad condition and prune the other four.

冧樹一刻曝光 7秒內瞓低險象環生!【般咸道冧大樹 扯冧護土牆壓男女】【冧樹一刻曝光 7秒內瞓低】【同區塌樹殺人 壓死孕婦最轟動】【塌樹列入古樹名木冊】【大樹塌向對面樓 掃甩冷氣機無損結構】【只差少少壓車頭 司機:咁我就玩完!】跟實我哋 【 現場 - 蘋果突發】就會知更多社會事#黃雨之災 #冧樹 #記者講兩句

Posted by 現場 - 蘋果突發 on 2015年7月21日

However, on Friday evening the Highways Department announced that the remaining four trees would be cut down because of cracks in the stone fence.

The move was controversial among local residents in Mid-Levels West.

On Sunday, August 9, district councillors and residents protested near the four tree stumps. On Wednesday a group of district councillors from the Central and Western District Council delivered a petition to the Highways Department’s office to protest its decision to go ahead with the felling without public consultation.

Democratic party district councillor Ted Hui Chi-fung told HKFP during the demonstration that there had been cracks on the upper part of the wall for a long time.

trailwatch sai wan concern
Authorities fell four banyan trees on Bonham Road. Photo: Trailwatch via Facebook.

Hong Kong University geography professor Jim Chi-yong, who is involved with the Expert Panel on Tree Management, described the move as “collateral murder” and said he was not informed of the decision to fell the fours trees until a reporter phoned him.

Vicky Wong

Vicky Wong

Vicky is a British-born Chinese journalist with three years of experience covering UK politics. She previously worked for PoliticsHome and has interned at Sky News and CNN International. She also co-produced and filmed a documentary about the Hong Kong protests for MSNBC, which won the grand student prize at the 2015 Human Rights Press Awards. She has a BA in Politics and International Relations from the University of Reading and moved to Hong Kong in 2014 to complete a journalism masters at the University of Hong Kong.